I have tried for so long to find a great eyeliner that I can actually afford!!  Someday I will be able to get all the expensive makeup but alas, today is not the day:)  For now, I have recently found this covergirl eyeliner that I am in love with. I really don't like pencil eyeliners, I have never found one that doesn't smudge after a few hours but liquid liners were really hard for me to maneuver.  This eyeliner is the perfect blend!  It's liquid liner BUT it is actually a little pen (like the mini-sharpies) and its SO EASY to use! It stays on all day and doesn't smudge!!  I definitely recommend it :)